The Safest Caribbean Islands to Visit: Best to Worst!
- Angie - Your Guide
- Aug 5
- 14 min read
Updated: Aug 5
The Caribbean calls to the spirit with its kaleidoscope of sapphire seas, palm-fringed sands, and a rhythm that pulses pure joy. Whether you’re dreaming of lazy days under cerulean skies or vibrant island fiestas, the Caribbean is a patchwork of cultures, cuisines, and adventures. But exploring paradise should always be carefree, and that’s why smart travelers place safety high on their checklists before jetting off.
With this guide, you'll get a panoramic view of the safety landscape across every Caribbean nation and territory, from the most tranquil hideaways to the places where a little extra caution goes a long way. For families, solo explorers, honeymoons or memory-makers of every kind, this ranking is your passport to planning with confidence!
Understanding the U.S. Department of State’s Travel Advisory System
Before we set sail on our safety ranking odyssey, let’s drop anchor and talk about perhaps the most influential compass for U.S. tourists: the U.S. Department of State’s travel advisories. This system uses color-coded “levels” to communicate risk in countries around the world.
Level 1: Exercise Normal Precautions (Green) – This is the gold standard! Countries at Level 1 are considered the safest for travel, having only the usual risks found globally.
Level 2: Exercise Increased Caution (Yellow) – Here, travelers should remain alert due to slightly elevated risks. This may include petty crime, natural disasters, periodic health alerts, or other particular issues.
Level 3: Reconsider Travel (Orange) – Destinations at Level 3 often face more serious security, health, or crime concerns. U.S. citizens are urged to consider whether travel is essential.
Level 4: Do Not Travel (Red) – This is the most severe warning. Level 4 advisories are reserved for places facing critical dangers such as war, civil unrest, kidnapping, or frequent violent crime.
It's essential to recognize that these levels aren’t based solely on tourist-targeted crime. The U.S. government takes a broad view, factoring in political stability, health care emergencies (like Zika or COVID-19 outbreaks), natural disasters, terrorism, and infrastructure issues—sometimes weighing risks that don’t generally affect mainstream travelers. For instance, a country may be ranked Level 2 not simply due to petty theft, but because of hurricane susceptibility, occasional demonstrations or medical services. In this guide, we'll note each country’s current advisory level and explain how that might affect your trip.
Personally I would visit all but 1 of these Caribbean countries, and even then given the right circumstances I would visit thar one. Whichever country you visit, it is a good idea to always be aware of your surroundings.
The safest Caribbean islands to visit list, is good for everyone traveling to the Caribbean. If you are doing an All-Inclusive resort on a tropical island, or just a visit to a port while on a cruise. It is a good to know the level of safety on the island around you. Media tends to focus on the horrible stories, that tend to scare people away from visiting an island, when there are so many good stories, vibrant cultures, and sweet people. In my eyes, it's always best to know what you are getting into and to be informed, but not to the point that it scares me away from visiting, if it is considered safe enough by US Standards to visit.
The Safest Caribbean Islands to Visit – Full Ranking and Detailed Guide
Let’s set sail! Here’s your ultimate, up-to-date ranking of every Caribbean country and territory, from safest to that best visited with caution. For each, you’ll find an overview, a snapshot of crime and safety, its U.S. State Department travel advisory level as of publication, and tips for happy, worry-free adventures.
1. Cayman Islands – Luxury Wrapped in Safety
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
The Cayman Islands (Grand Cayman, Cayman Brac, and Little Cayman) consistently top safety lists. With sparkling coral reefs, world-class dining, and a steadfast focus on traveler security, these islands roll out the welcome mat with panache. Locals are proud of their low crime rate, which is reflected in the rare instances of even petty theft, especially in tourist zones.
The government invests in robust infrastructure and visible policing in tourism districts, especially in areas like Seven Mile Beach, and downtown Georgetown. The Level 1 rating is considered accurate, as risks here are minimal, and the majority of U.S. visitors face no safety-related issues. So visit the beaches, go to stingray city, or walk around the city of Georgetown. Whatever you do you should feel safe.
2. Anguilla – Tranquility with a Side of Safety
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
Dreamy, friendly, and blessed with soft white beaches, the best beaches lined with palm trees. Anguilla is about as serene as it gets. The low-key vibe goes hand-in-hand with negligible crime targeting travelers. Police presence is casual but effective, and the risk of serious incidents is tiny.
The Level 1 advisory reflects the almost idyllic safety record; any warnings are typically related to basic precautions, like safeguarding valuables on the beach. Making this one of the safest places to visit.
3. Montserrat – The Emerald Isle of the Caribbean
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
Despite its volcanic history, Montserrat is a sanctuary of calm. With a population under 5,000, the community is close-knit and visitors are genuinely welcomed. Crime is rare, and the biggest risks are natural (the volcano is closely monitored, and affected areas are off-limits).
Travel advisories rarely highlight crime here. Instead, their level 1 rating accounts for the island's general tranquility, with natural risks well-managed and clearly communicated.
4. British Virgin Islands – Safe Harbors and Stunning Views
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
From coral atolls to yacht-filled harbors, the British Virgin Islands make safety a seamless part of the guest experience. Major incidents are very rare: crime typically means non-confrontational theft of unlocked items. Considered a safe place for solo travelers also. The Level 1 advisory is justified, and while hurricanes remain a seasonal concern, the territory responds swiftly to any threats, keeping visitors well informed.
5. Barbados – Sun, Sand, and Security
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
Barbados is a vibrant mix of hospitality and order. Popular with Americans, Brits, and Canadians, the island puts a premium on visitor safety through policies and policing that actively discourage crime.
The State Department considers risk exceedingly low; petty theft can occur in tourist areas, but major crime is rare. Water is safe, infrastructure is modern, and emergencies are skillfully managed, supporting its Level 1 status.
6. Bonaire – Diver’s Paradise with Peace of Mind
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
Undersea adventures and peaceful vibes define Bonaire, where safety is as deep as its waters. Crime is almost unheard of and largely limited to minor property theft if things are left unattended.
Travel advisories stress routine caution only. Hurricanes are rare, and local authorities are diligent about visitor wellbeing, which fits the Level 1 profile.
7. St. Pierre & Miquelon – French Island Safety in the Atlantic
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
Technically just north of the Caribbean, this French territory has zero violent crime and almost no petty theft. one of the safest islands in the Caribbean. Its green advisory level notes the area’s strict enforcement of law. Travelers are more likely to encounter fog than trouble, and natural risks are minimal.
8. Saint Barthelemy (St. Barts) – Chic and Secure
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
The playground of the rich and famous is also one of the region’s safest picks. The atmosphere is relaxed, security is subtle, and the chance of facing crime is extremely slim. Unfussy, posh, and peaceful, with white sand beaches, St. Barts excels at keeping travelers happy and safe.
Level 1 advisories mention routine caution, but the focus is often on weather patterns and safeguarding valuables—not serious threats.
9. Saint Kitts and Nevis – Small Nation, Big Hospitality
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
Tourist-focused and community-oriented, this dual-island nation keeps its crime stats low. Some crimes (mainly theft or petty crimes) can occur, but rarely impact tourists due to strong policing in vacation areas.
Level 1 status reflects robust response to hurricanes and efficient emergency services, making St. Kitts and Nevis a top safe pick.
10. Aruba – Happiness is Safety
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
Aruba sparkles with friendliness, beautiful beaches, and generally low crime. There can be theft in busy areas, especially if valuables are left unattended. Violent crime affecting tourists is rare. I know everyone remembers back to the disappearance of Natalie Holloway many year ago, but never let that stop you from visiting this place.
The State Department’s green light reflects this, with most advice revolving around health and weather preparedness. Aruba's infrastructure is one of the best of the Caribbean Island. You are in a safe environment when you are here.
11. Saint Lucia – Romance with Reassurance
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
St. Lucia is stunning, and its tourist areas are generally safe. Petty theft is possible in some areas, but resorts often have private security and guide guests about safe excursions. This is a safe island, one of the safest, most commonly known for its luxury resorts.
Level 1 underscores low risk, robust police, and well-maintained infrastructure.
12. Martinique – French Flair and Strong Safety
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
This French overseas region has modern infrastructure and excellent healthcare. Low Crime rates, mostly minor thefts, and weather preparation is top-notch.
Travelers benefit from the island’s emergency planning and strong law enforcement.
13. Dominica – Nature Island, Naturally Safe
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
With rainforest hikes and hidden pools, Dominica is bliss for outdoor lovers. Violent crime is nearly nonexistent but keep an eye on belongings. Travel advisories are usually focused on weather risks, as Dominica is prone to storms. The community spirit here is infectious—and protective.
14. Grenada – Spice Island with a Dash of Diligence
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
Grenada is friendly and largely peaceful. Resorts are secure, and locals respect visitors. Theft occurs, but seldom impacts visitors who stick to the usual cautionary measures.
The green ranking emphasizes preparedness for hurricanes and the low crime threat.
15. Antigua and Barbuda – Twin Islands, Safe Shores
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
Among the safest spots in the region, Antigua and Barbuda welcome tourists with smiles and a gentle pace. Crime is rare; the main risks are natural (hurricanes).
The advisory level highlights these minor concerns, so pack sunscreen and common sense! When I was visiting these 2 islands, I felt no concern at all. But while riding in a van from the cruise port to a beach on the other side of the island, I did ride through a part of town I would have not felt comfortable walking through alone.
16. Sint Eustatius & Saba – Hidden Dutch Gems
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
Tiny and tranquil, these islands see nearly no crime. The main travel cautions pertain to weather and the steep terrain.
Saba is such a small island, I was just offshore on a tour from a visiting island and was told it was Saba. It looks like a mountain coming out of the water. Without a huge population. Visiting here means wandering safe paths and enjoying local hospitality untroubled.
17. Saint Vincent & the Grenadines – Laid Back but Mindful
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
Sailing, beachcombing, crystal clear waters, and volcanic vistas color this nation’s appeal. Petty theft can occur in crowded market areas. The advisory system mostly notes seasonal storms, and serious problems are rare. Reports of theft in busy markets are occasional, not pervasive. The islands are largely peaceful for visitors.
18. Guadeloupe – French Sophistication and Local Caution
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
Guadeloupe exudes French-Caribbean charm with turquoise waters. Tourist-targeted crime is low, but in some urban areas, travelers should be alert.
The State Department gives a green level but suggests standard vigilance and watching for weather warnings. Minor thefts, if any, and excellent healthcare provide peace of mind for adventurers.
19. Bermuda – Distant Atlantic Safety
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 1 – Exercise Normal Precautions
Though not a classic Caribbean island, and one of a few British overseas territories in the area, Bermuda's tropical vibe and low crime make it safe for most travelers.
Occasional minor thefts or hurricanes are the main risks. Tourist safety is always a high priority here.
The U.S. rating is green, and most advice is about weather and routine security.
20. Turks & Caicos Islands – Refined Relaxation
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 2 – Exercise Increased Caution
Grace Bay’s shimmering sands attract many, and this British territory’s main risk is petty crime in tourist hotspots. Violent crime is rare and usually not aimed at travelers.
The Level 2 advisory is mostly due to opportunistic theft—so keep an eye on your belongings, especially in crowded places. The government works closely with the tourism sector for swift safety responses. I have often thought that these islands have friendly people in the Caribbean, or maybe it was just from my experience.
21. Curacao – Colorful, Cosmopolitan & Cautious
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 2 – Exercise Increased Caution
Curacao’s charming capital and sun-drenched beaches are very safe, though some neighborhoods see occasional robberies or petty theft, especially after dark. Level 2 primarily acknowledges increased caution at night and in non-tourist areas. Overall, resorts, beaches, and major attractions are safe, but vigilance is wise.
Everyone right now is talking about a disappearance from almost 30 years ago due to a Netflix series. The story of Amy Bradley is distressing, and we may never know what truly happened, or if she is still alive. But her disappearance would never stop me from visiting this island on a cruise or an extended stay at a resort.
22 and 23. Sint Maarten/Saint Martin – Vibrant Split Island
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 2 – Exercise Increased Caution
Both the Dutch and French sides offer fun, friendly travel but see some petty crime (thefts from rental cars, pickpocketing). Serious incidents involving tourists are rare.
Level 2 reflects these risks, and the advisory also considers hurricane season disruptions.
22. Sint Maarten (Dutch Side) – Cautious Fun
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 2 – Exercise Increased Caution
Like its French counterpart, this half of the island is safe in main zones but advises against venturing alone at night in certain neighborhoods. Hurricanes are also a concern seasonally.
23. St. Martin (French Side) – Laidback and Watchful
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 2 – Exercise Increased Caution
This side of the island is equally fun and mostly safe, but keep a watch out for petty theft, especially at nightlife venues. Cruise ships dock on the French side and one time when I visited via a cruise ship, we were delayed getting off the cruise ship for about 30 minutes because a robbery of a jewelry store near the port was taking place and authorities asked cruise ships to wait till things calmed down. By the time I got off the cruise ship there was not even a police presence in the port area. Later that day I asked around and it was said the police caught the individuals almost immediately who robbed the jewelry store.
24. US Virgin Islands – Easy Paradise for Americans
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 2 – Exercise Increased Caution
Like Puerto Rico, this territory is a breeze for U.S. travelers. Tourist areas are generally safe, but some crime affects locals and the unwary, mostly in certain St. Thomas neighborhoods. I have always enjoyed my time snorkeling and scuba diving off the coast of St John or St Croix, but snorkeling at St Thomas is great too.
Level 2 is due to urban crime, hurricane risk, and periodic health warnings. This might shock many of you reading this list, as it is a US territory, but just because it is a US territory does not mean it is as safe as places in the United States, but in my eyes, it is safer than New York City.
25. Trinidad and Tobago – Carnival Energy with Caution
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 2 – Exercise Increased Caution
The country hosts vibrant festivals, but urban Trinidad in particular sees violent and gang-related crime. Tourist zones have increased security.
State Department cautions relate mostly to crime, as well as periodic flooding and demonstrations.
26. The Bahamas – Sun, Sand, and Sensible Caution
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 2 – Exercise Increased Caution
While most trips are trouble-free, Nassau and Freeport see occasional higher crime. Resorts and out islands remain safe for families and the majority of tourists. This is one the most popular Caribbean destinations.
Level 2 comes due to urban crime and periodic hurricane threats. Follow hotel safety advice, stay aware in cities, and you’ll discover this archipelago’s joy with few worries.
I have traveled to several islands in the Bahamas and never felt unsafe.
27. Dominican Republic – Packed with Sights, Use Caution
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 2 – Exercise Increased Caution
Tourism is robust, but crime (including theft and scams) is more common, especially in Santo Domingo and resort outskirts. Advisory level 2 is in part due to crime, as well as risk of hurricanes and at times, demonstrations. That said, the vast majority of trips are incident-free, especially within resort zones. This is the perfect place for all-inclusive vacations, but many stay at the resorts and don't venture out into the country much.
28. Puerto Rico (U.S.) – Festive, Familiar, and Friendly
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 2 – Exercise Increased Caution
As a U.S. territory, Puerto Rico is popular for easy entry. Petty crime, particularly in San Juan, can occur. Violent incidents rarely affect tourists.
Level 2 relates to these urban issues, infrastructure recovery post-hurricanes, and health advisories. I have visited this island several times and never felt unsafe, But I was never on the streets alone at night in downtown San Juan.
29. Cuba – Travel with Awareness
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 2 – Exercise Increased Caution
Cuba feels lively and safe in tourist districts. Petty theft and scams are the main risks for travelers, and violent crime is rare. Occasional shortages and protests prompt caution.
The level 2 classification is influenced by government policies, unpredictable shortages, and periodic demonstrations.
30. Jamaica – Culture with Care
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 2– Reconsider Travel *Recent Change)
Jamaica dazzles with reggae and natural beauty, but certain urban zones face high violent crime rates. Tourist areas and resorts employ strong security, and most visitors—especially those joining organized tours or staying in secure properties—enjoy carefree vacations.
Jamaica was a Level 3 in May of 2025, but the level has now been lowered to a level 2, which is a great improvement. This is due to the prevalence of violent crime, high crime rates and occasionally limited police response times outside resorts. Follow hotel guidance, be alert, and arrange safe transport after dark.
My time in Montego Bay was just after the US warning came out as a level 3, I did not feel unsafe walking, but would highly recommend taking tours, or hiring drivers to take you to places. While staying in a resort, the resorts can help you plan excursions or even a travel agent. This way you will be safe in this country.
31. Haiti – Rich Culture Amid Challenges
U.S. State Department Advisory: Level 4 – Do Not Travel
From history to art, Haiti inspires—but the U.S. strongly advises against travel here due to political instability, civil unrest, natural disasters, and high rates of violent crime.
The advisory is not just about tourist risks but the unpredictability of major events. Even aid workers and journalists face substantial danger. Also, you might recall, Labadee Haiti is a stop for Royal Caribbean cruise ships. This section is very safe, protected by the security of the cruise line. If I take a Royal Caribbean cruise that stops at this port, I will have no problem visiting Haiti.
32. Navassa Island (U.S.) – Not Open to Tourists
U.S. State Department Advisory: N/A (Uninhabited)
No travel or safety concerns apply, as this is a nature preserve and closed to visitors.
Safety Tips for Every Adventure
No matter where your wanderlust carries you across this sparkling sea of possibility, a bit of planning and savvy goes a long way. Remember to:
Check the latest official travel advisories: The U.S. Embassy and local government sites keep you current.
Secure your belongings and keep valuables close, especially at beaches and city centers.
Use only marked, official taxis and reputable tour operators.
Take extra care at night and stick to well-lit, populated places.
Respect local customs, heed weather warnings (especially during hurricane season), and stay informed through your hotel or resort.
Purchase travel insurance that covers health, accident, and evacuation.
Conclusion
The Caribbean offers something sensational for every traveler, from serene stretches of white sand to kaleidoscopic carnivals. With a mix of sunny optimism and practical know-how—including the wisdom of U.S. State Department advisories—you’ll be well-equipped to savor every moment safely. So, grab your sunglasses, chase the horizon, and remember: the adventure of a lifetime starts with a little smart planning and a lot of zest for discovery!
(Note: The safety rankings and advisory levels in this guide are based on current sources at the time of writing. Conditions can change rapidly, so always consult official travel advice and local resources before booking your trip. Bon voyage!)
This blog contains affiliate links. If you click on them and make a purchase, I might receive a commission at no extra cost to you.