Princess Cruises vs Carnival Cruises: Which is Best!
- Angie - Your Guide
- Jul 17
- 14 min read
Table of Contents
When considering a cruise vacation, two prominent names often come up—Princess Cruises vs Carnival Cruises. Though both operate under the same parent company, Carnival Corporation & plc, they offer distinctly different experiences. Whether you're looking for a luxury getaway or a lively, budget-friendly escape, understanding how these two cruise lines compare can help you plan the vacation of your dreams.
This blog examines everything you need to know about these cruise lines, including their history, destinations, pricing, food, entertainment, demographics, and unique features. We'll also wrap things up with a summary chart of pros and cons, making it easy to see which cruise line fits your needs.
A Shared Parent, Different Stories
Carnival Cruises
Carnival Cruises, established in 1972, is the flagship brand of Carnival Corporation & plc. Known as the "Fun Ships," Carnival focuses on providing an affordable and lively vacation experience. This cruise line is perfect for those who love thrilling activities, vibrant atmosphere and non-stop fun. Over the years, Carnival has gained a reputation as the go-to line for families, groups of friends, and first-time cruisers.
Princess Cruises
On the other hand, Princess Cruises, founded in 1965, positions itself as a premium cruise line. Gaining fame thanks to the TV show The Love Boat in the 1970s, Princess strives to deliver a more sophisticated and serene experience. It caters to couples, retirees, and travelers seeking understated elegance and enrichment.
Though both lines operate under the Carnival umbrella, their distinct identities appeal to different kinds of travelers.
Destinations: Where Can You Cruise?
Carnival Cruises’ Reach
Carnival Cruises primarily operates in North America, sailing to popular destinations such as the Caribbean, Bahamas, Mexico, and Alaska. They also offer limited options to Europe, Australia, and select exotic locales. With shorter itineraries ranging from 3 to 5 days, Carnival appeals to those seeking quick and affordable getaways. The Caribbean cruise is the most popular with this cruise line.
Princess Cruises’ Global Scope
Princess Cruises takes a more global approach, traveling to over 300 destinations. Popular routes include Europe, Asia, Australia, New Zealand, South America, and Alaska. With longer itineraries that can extend up to several weeks, Princess caters to avid travelers who crave experiencing the world. Princess sails in the Caribbean too, just like Carnival, but is known in the cruise industry as going to more destinations around the world
Pricing Comparison
When it comes to affordability, Carnival Cruises takes the crown. Their cruises typically start at around $200 per person for shorter trips, making it an excellent option for budget-conscious travelers. Specialty dining and add-ons are also reasonably priced, which keeps the experience accessible.
Princess Cruises, while still competitive, comes with a higher price tag—reflecting its more upscale amenities and offerings. Expect rates to start closer to $400 per person for short cruises. If you're looking for a luxury experience at a cost-effective rate, Princess still offers good value for what it provides.
One thing I have found that even Carnival can be better priced. It is not always the case. I have found since I am a travel agent, Princess Cruise Line has consistently had better prices than Carnival when it comes to Alaskan Cruises. From Interior rooms to Balcony Cabins, I have found Princess to be better prices for Alaska.
Age Demographics
Each cruise line attracts a specific kind of traveler:
Carnival Cruises are popular among younger families, singles, young couples, and thrill-seekers. Their fun, high-energy atmosphere often draws a crowd with an average age range of 30-50.
Princess Cruises appeals to older couples and retirees, with a more relaxed vibe and enrichment-focused activities. Their average passenger age is typically around 55 and older, though multi-generational families also enjoy the amenities.
Dining and Cuisine
Some things are similar, but many are different. Sure both cruise lines have a buffet, main dining room, and outdoor dining near the pools. But there are major differences in style, and cuisine. Casual Specialty meals can be found on both cruise lines, but for the most part with both you will need to dress up a little bit more for the main dining room and Specialty restaurants.
Carnival Cruises' Dining
Carnival is all about casual but satisfying fare. Their main dining rooms and expansive buffet cater to a variety of palates, offering everything from classic American dishes to international options. Specialty options like Guy’s Burger Joint and Blue Iguana Cantina are fan favorites for adding flair to the onboard dining experience. While the food is crowd-pleasing, it may lack the gourmet touch some travelers crave. Carnival Fans also say that they have the best pizza.
Princess Cruises' Culinary Excellence
Princess Cruises prides itself on an elevated dining experience. Guests can savor multi-course gourmet meals in luxurious dining rooms, along with specialty restaurants like Sabatini's for Italian cuisine or Crown Grill for premium steak and seafood. The line is also known for its chef partnerships, bringing distinctive regional flavors to your plate. It's a perfect match for those who love fine dining.
Entertainment Options
Both cruise lines have plenty of entertainment, from live music on the pool deck and plenty of bars scattered all around the ships. A casino, games, and shows in the theaters.
Carnival Cruises' High-Energy Fun
True to its spirit, Carnival offers nonstop action both day and night. From waterslides and ropes courses to award-winning comedy clubs and thrilling late-night parties, there's rarely a dull moment. Live performances, DJs, and nightlife are highlights of the Carnival experience, perfectly suited for those who want to keep the energy flowing. If you want water parks, and roller coasters. Carnival is the way to go. Many kids activities and kids clubs too.
Princess Cruises' Elegant Enrichment
Princess focuses on more refined forms of entertainment. Guests can enjoy Broadway-style productions, classical music performances, and nature documentaries in partnership with Discovery™ at SEA. The enrichment goes further with lectures, wine tastings, and cooking classes. Entertainment on Princess feels more tailored for those seeking leisure over adrenaline. You will still find kids clubs and plenty for kids to enjoy on Princess, plus pools and hot tubs
Fleet Size
Carnival Cruises operates a fleet of 25 ships—the largest in the industry—making it a powerhouse for choices. Smaller ships tend to the oldest in the fleet, with new ships like the Carnival Celebration and the Carnival Mardi Gras being the largest in their fleet.
Princess Cruises boasts 15 elegant ships, small enough to provide a personal touch while still offering plenty of options. From the Sun Princess as the largest to the Coral Princess as the smallest and the Grand Princess right in the middle.
Ratings and Reviews
Carnival Cruises
Carnival passengers often commend the cruise line for its affordability, family-friendly vibe, and expansive activities. However, reviews sometimes note overcrowding and a lack of premium feel. First time cruisers enjoy this cruise line and tend to come back but often check out other cruise lines too.
Princess Cruises
Reviews for Princess Cruises highlight the luxurious cabins, exceptional dining, and quieter, more sophisticated atmosphere. However, some mention higher costs as a downside. Those who travel Princess tend to have the most loyal customers, coming back to this cruise line time and time again due to feeling like an elite passenger, even if the prices are more expensive.
Medallion vs Key Card Systems
This is a major difference between both cruise lines, and those that cruise with Princess finds it hard to go back to the cruise card, just because the Medallion is so much better.
Princess Cruises sets itself apart with its Medallion system, a coin-sized device that streamlines the guest experience. From keyless room entry to contactless payments and even locating loved ones on the ship, this technology adds convenience and personalization. For example, You order food, and are finding a seat on the pool deck. The servers will bring it to you, knowing your location thanks to the Medallion. It is a very neat thing Princess offers.
Carnival cruisers, in contrast, use the traditional key card system. Though it gets the job done, it lacks the innovation and user-friendliness of the Medallion.
Loyalty Programs for Both Cruise Lines.
When planning a cruise vacation, the perks offered through loyalty programs can make a real difference in your experience. Both Princess Cruises and Carnival Cruises, two of the world's most popular cruise lines, have established loyalty programs to reward frequent travelers. Princess Cruises offers the Captain’s Circle, while Carnival Cruises features the VIFP Club (Very Important Fun Person). Though both aim to enhance the cruising experience for loyal guests, their structure, benefits, and appeal to different traveler types vary significantly.
The only issue right now that I will point out is that Carnival brand has said their loyalty program is changing effective June of 2026. It is going to be based more on how much money you spend versus the point system they have used in the past. Due to the major differences, and possible changes over the next few months that Carnival might make before the roll out next year, I would say if this were going to be your first cruise, don't worry about loyalty programs yet. But if you are a seasoned cruiser, you might want to think harder on which cruise line suits you better for the long run. You will need to cruise mostly with Carnival and stick with it to get the loyalty program to work for you.
Drink Package Comparisons
Understanding the beverage options offered by a cruise line can significantly enhance your vacation experience. After all, what’s better than sipping on your favorite drink while gazing out over the open ocean? Both Princess Cruises and Carnival Cruises offer drink packages designed to make your getaway worry-free and indulgent. But which cruise line offers the better package for your preferences? We’re breaking it all down—from pricing and inclusions to restrictions and overall value—so you can toast the good times no matter which line you choose.
Princess Cruises Drink Packages
1. Princess Plus Beverage Package
The Plus Beverage Package is Princess ships go-to offering for guests aiming to have their drink needs covered. It’s designed for travelers looking to enjoy a mix of alcoholic and non-alcoholic options during their voyage.
What’s Included?
Premium cocktails, wines by the glass, and beers (up to $15 per drink).
Non-alcoholic options, including specialty coffees, teas, fresh juices, and mocktails.
Bottled water.
Soda (fountain and canned soft drinks).
Pricing: The Plus Beverage Package is priced at $64.99 per person, per day, plus an 18% service charge.
2. Princess Premier Beverage Package
For those who enjoy top-shelf choices and additional perks, Princess Cruises also offers the Premier Beverage Package, an elevated version of their Plus Package.
What’s Included?
Everything in the Plus Beverage Package.
Higher drink value limit (up to $20 per drink).
Expanded top-shelf spirit options and premium wines by the glass.
Pricing: The Premier Beverage Package costs $84.99 per person, per day, plus an 18% service charge.
Restrictions and Notes
Each package is only available to passengers aged 21 and over.
A daily purchase limit of 15 alcoholic beverages applies.
Packages must be purchased for the entirety of the cruise.
Sharing drink packages with others is not permitted.
Best Fit
Princess Cruises’ drink packages suit travelers seeking a sophisticated drinking experience, with premium wines, artisanal cocktails, and rich coffee offerings. It’s ideal for guests who enjoy finer things or plan to indulge in a variety of drinks over their voyage.
Carnival Cruises Drink Packages
1. Cheers! Program
Carnival Cruise ships primary all-inclusive drink package is the aptly named Cheers! Program. Designed with Carnival’s fun-loving crowd in mind, this package ensures party-goers can indulge without constantly fretting about individual drink costs.
What’s Included?
Unlimited access to alcoholic beverages, including wine, spirits, beer, and cocktails (value up to $20 per drink).
Non-alcoholic options like specialty coffees, sodas, energy drinks, bottled water, and shakes.
Discounts on bottles of wine purchased at onboard restaurants (25% off).
Access to frozen cocktails and mocktails.
Pricing: Cheers! The program is priced at $59.95 per person, per day if purchased in advance or $64.95 per person, per day if purchased onboard, plus a 20% service charge.
2. Bottomless Bubbles
If alcohol isn’t on your radar but unlimited soft drinks are, Carnival offers the more budget-friendly Bottomless Bubbles package.
What’s Included?
Unlimited sodas.
Unlimited juices.
Pricing: The Bottomless Bubbles package costs $6.95 per day for kids (under 18) and $9.95 per day for adults, plus an 18% service charge.
Restrictions and Notes
Cheers! The program is available to passengers 21 years or older.
A daily limit of 15 alcoholic drinks applies, but there’s no cap on non-alcoholic beverages.
Guests must purchase the package for the entire duration of the cruise.
Sharing or “splitting” packages is prohibited.
Best Fit
Carnival’s Cheers! The program is perfect for those who love a lively, high-energy vibe and want a wide variety of drinks, from cocktails to energy drinks, included in their package. The Bottomless Bubbles package offers excellent value for families or anyone who sticks to non-alcoholic options.
Breaking Down the Key Differences
1. Pricing
When it comes to all-inclusive drink packages, Carnival’s Cheers! The Program comes in slightly cheaper than Princess Cruises’ Plus Beverage Package. However, Carnival’s pricing advantage is reduced by its higher service charge rate (20% compared to Princess’ 18%).
2. Drink Value Limits
Princess Cruises’ entry-level Plus Beverage Package includes drinks up to $15 in value, while Carnival’s Cheers! The program offers a slightly higher allowance at $20 per drink. If you’re someone who enjoys high-end cocktails or top-shelf wine and spirits, Carnival offers slightly more flexibility.
3. Non-Alcoholic Options
Both cruise lines include unlimited soft drinks, bottled water, and specialty coffees in their packages. However, Princess Cruises offers additional perks like fresh juices and premium teas, appealing to those who savor non-alcoholic indulgences.
4. Atmosphere and Suitability
Princess Cruises’ drink packages complement its refined and laid-back atmosphere, focusing on a mix of luxury and leisure.
Carnival’s Cheers! The program reflects its vibrant energy, perfect for socializing, celebrating, or just plain relaxing.
5. Specialized Non-Alcoholic Packages
Carnival stands out with its dedicated non-alcoholic Bottomless Bubbles option, which is particularly budget-friendly for families. Princess Cruises lacks an equivalent option for kids or guests not interested in alcoholic beverages.
6. Exclusions
Both cruise lines enforce similar exclusions, such as no beverages served in souvenir glasses, no room service or minibar drinks, and no sharing between passengers. However, Carnival’s Cheers! The program does provide discounts on wine bottle purchases, which Princess doesn’t offer in its packages.
Which Cruise Line’s Drink Package Is Better for You?
Choosing the right drink package comes down to your cruising style, preferences, and budget.
For Premium Drinkers and Coffee Connoisseurs: Princess Cruises’ Plus Beverage Package caters to those who prioritize quality. The inclusion of fresh juices and premium coffee makes it a standout for travelers who enjoy more than just alcoholic beverages.
For Party-Loving Socialites: Carnival Cruises’ Cheers! The program is better suited for outgoing cruisers who enjoy top-shelf cocktails, frozen drinks, and sodas while taking advantage of Carnival’s lively atmosphere.
For Families and Budget Travelers: Carnival’s Bottomless Bubbles package is a solid pick for families or cruise-goers who don’t drink alcohol but still want to enjoy unlimited soft drink options.
Wi-Fi Packages Comparisons
A vacation at sea doesn’t have to mean dropping off the digital grid—unless you want it to! Both Princess Cruises and Carnival Cruises offer Wi-Fi packages to keep you connected, whether you’re scrolling through social media, streaming your favorite shows, or emailing a sunset photo to your coworkers (because who doesn’t love a little humble bragging?).
But not all internet offerings are created equal, especially when navigating a vast ocean. From pricing and speed to reliability and device restrictions, this guide dives into the nitty-gritty of Wi-Fi on Princess and Carnival cruises to help you make the best decision for your cruising style.
Princess Cruises
Princess Cruises offers two primary tiers of internet service under the name MedallionNet Wi-Fi, which leverages advanced technology to deliver faster speeds and reliable connectivity.
Basic Wi-Fi Package
Includes access to social media, email, and limited browsing.
Suitable for casual users who just want to stay socially connected.
Premium Wi-Fi Package (Unlimited Wifi)
Provides full internet access, including streaming, video calls, and more data-heavy activities.
Designed for travelers who need regular internet access or want to stream content like Netflix.
Pricing: Packages typically range from $9.99–$15.99 per day per device, with discounts for pre-purchasing before boarding. Costs vary slightly based on the cruise itinerary and duration.
One standout feature of MedallionNet is its device-flexibility, as you can switch your connection from one device to another seamlessly.
Carnival Cruises
Carnival’s internet offerings are divided into three tiers under the Wi-Fi@Sea Program, catering to different levels of connectivity needs.
Social Plan
Aimed at social media enthusiasts, this plan only supports apps like Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp, and Twitter.
Does not include general web browsing or email access.
Value Plan
Includes features of the Social Plan plus access to emails and basic browsing. Streaming services and certain apps that use high bandwidth remain restricted.
Premium Plan
Carnival’s highest tier, offering the fastest speeds for functionalities like streaming, video calls, and VPN access.
Ideal for remote workers or those who need reliable high-speed internet.
Pricing
Social Plan starts at $8.50 per day.
Value Plan costs approximately $12.75 per day.
Premium Plan ranges from $17–$20 per day.
Discounts for multi-day or pre-purchased packages are available. Device usage is typically limited to one per login, so bring extra gadgets cautiously!
Performance at Sea: Speed and Reliability
Princess Cruises’ MedallionNet
Dubbed the “Best Wi-Fi at Sea,” Princess Cruises’ MedallionNet builds on advanced satellite technology, offering consistent and dependable connectivity. Speeds are widely praised, with most passengers reporting smooth streaming and a seamless browsing experience. Unlike many other cruise services, MedallionNet provides excellent coverage not only in public areas but also in cabins. It’s especially reliable for video calls and online work, making it a favorite for digital nomads.
Reliability rating: High
Speed rating: Very high for a cruise line
Coverage rating: Robust, even in private staterooms
Carnival Cruises Wi-Fi@Sea
Carnival’s internet service is functional but less robust compared to Princess. Speeds are acceptable for basic browsing or social use under the Social or Value Plans. The Premium Plan provides a better experience for streaming or work-related tasks; however, some passengers report intermittent lags, especially during peak usage times. Coverage is adequate in common areas but can falter in interior cabins.
Reliability rating: Moderate
Speed rating: Good for emails and browsing; less consistent for heavy streaming
Coverage rating: Adequate, with some room for improvement
Pro Tip: Whether you’re on a Princess or Carnival ship, performance tends to vary based on the ship's proximity to port and other external conditions. Peak times (like early mornings or evenings, when everyone is trying to connect) can also slow things down on both lines.
Restrictions and Limitations
Despite their strengths, both cruise lines impose certain limitations. Here’s where they differ:
Restriction | Princess Cruises | Carnival Cruises |
Device Limits | No set limit; switch between devices | One device per login |
Data Caps | Unlimited for Premium Plan | Unlimited for Premium Plan |
Streaming Access | Available on Premium Package | Only on Premium Plan |
Social Plan Coverage | Not offered | Social apps only |
Princess’ flexibility in device switching stands out as a major convenience for families or travelers juggling multiple gadgets. Carnival’s one-device rule can feel limiting but works for solo cruisers with minimal internet needs.
Value for Different Traveler Types
For Casual Users: If staying updated on social media and occasionally browsing the web is enough for you, Carnival’s affordable Social Plan offers unbeatable value at just $8.50 per day. Meanwhile, Princess’ Basic plan provides better overall freedom but at a slightly higher price.
For Streaming Enthusiasts and Gamers: To stream videos or play games without frustration, Princess Cruises’ Premium Package wins thanks to its superior speed and connectivity. Carnival’s Premium option is passable but requires patience during high-traffic times.
For Remote Workers and Business Travelers: For professionals who need VPN access and reliable conference-call-friendly Wi-Fi, Princess Cruises’ MedallionNet gives you the best shot at staying productive on the high seas. Carnival’s Premium Plan works but may lag due to reliability inconsistencies.
For Families or Multi-Device Users: Princess Cruises outshines here, as their packages allow users to switch easily between devices. Carnival’s one-login configuration might cause headaches for those sharing an account.
Princess Cruises VS Carnival Cruises: Summary Comparison Table
Feature | Princess Cruises | Carnival Cruises |
Parent Corporation | Carnival Corporation & plc | Carnival Corporation & plc |
Founded | 1965 | 1972 |
Destinations | Global (300+ destinations) | Primarily North America, Caribbean |
Pricing | Higher (starting ~$400/person) | Budget-friendly (starting ~$200/person), better value |
Demographics | Couples, retirees, luxury seekers | Families, young adults, party-goers |
Dining | Gourmet, fine dining options | Casual, crowd-pleasing fare |
Entertainment | Elegant, enrichment-focused | High-energy, action-packed |
Fleet Size | 15 ships | 25 ships |
Unique Feature | Medallion technology | Traditional key card |
Pros | Luxe experience, global itineraries | Fun vibe, affordable making it accessible |
Cons | Higher cost | Can feel crowded |
Drink Packages | More costly but covers more options. | Still expensive, but worth it is you drink many drinks a day |
Wi-Fi | More flexibility, and consistent speed | Has more affordable options for users not online as often |
Final Thoughts
Choosing between Princess Cruises vs Carnival Cruises ultimately depends on your travel style. If you seek luxury, gourmet meals, and a calm atmosphere, Princess Cruises is your best bet. For affordability, family fun, and endless excitement, Carnival Cruises delivers value like no other. No matter which you pick, unforgettable memories are just a shipboard adventure away. Both cruise lines bring something unique to the table, so why not match the voyage to your mood? Craving some peace and quiet with serene sunsets? Princess Cruises will have you wrapped in elegance and relaxation. Longing for lively poolside parties, energetic entertainment, and a festive atmosphere? Carnival Cruises will keep your days buzzing with excitement. At the end of the day, it’s all about making those ocean-bound dreams come true, one wave at a time. Happy cruising!
This blog contains affiliate links. If you click on them and make a purchase, I might receive a commission at no extra cost to you.
This will be very helpful for my next cruise! Thank you!
This is a really helpful comparison between Princess Cruises and Carnival Cruises! I found the breakdown of dining options particularly interesting. I'm a bit of a foodie, so the detail about Princess's specialty restaurants versus Carnival's buffet focus gives me a lot to consider for my next cruise. Thanks for this insightful review!
Thank you for this detailed comparison between Princess Cruises and Carnival Cruises... really helpful to narrow it down! Princess Cruises would be more suitable for me!
i've only been on one cruise, so I was not aware that the brands are so markedly different. This is good to know since I am now looking for more family friendly/affordable options.
NNever been on a cruise, but if I had to choose, it would be Princess Cruises for me. It is nice to dream of a bit of luxury and calm amidst the vast ocean.